hmmm I dont really know...I wear the same makeup all the time (day or night) Foundation, concealer, concealer powder, blush, lipgloss, liquid eyeliner(top lid) reg. liner (bottom lid) 3x different mascaras, eyeshadow and then clear eyeliner

geez LOL till I wrote that I didnt think it was that much my gawd! haha
umm...Kate all I know is that they say you should pick a 'focus' point, like eyes OR lips...I know because I have very black eye makeup all the time, I look ridiculous with red lipstick as well for example...like they are competing?? I would say either do some smoky smouldering eyes and just a nude or clear lip gloss or just a little eye makeup and strong lips

*wolf whistles* hehehe