Dinnerly vs My Foodie Box vs Pepper Leaf

All three are meal kits you cook. Published ongoing prices: Dinnerly $8.99 a serving on a 6-serving order and My Foodie Box $15.33 a serving on a 6-serving order. Pepper Leaf does not publish an ongoing price.

Dinnerlymeal kit
My Foodie Boxmeal kit
Pepper Leafmeal kit
Prices checked 24 August 2026

Change the services compared

Service 1

Service 2

Add a third

Pick two or three services.

Side by side

Dinnerly vs My Foodie Box vs Pepper Leaf compared
Green: best value in the row, shown only when every service has one	Dinnerly Dinnerly review Visit site	My Foodie Box My Foodie Box review Visit site	Pepper Leaf Pepper Leaf review Visit site
Price and ordering	Dinnerly	My Foodie Box	Pepper Leaf
Ongoing priceBefore delivery fees and first-order offers	Dinnerly $8.99per serving, on a 6-serving order	My Foodie Box $15.33per serving, on a 6-serving order	Pepper Leaf Price not published
What the price is based on	Dinnerly Per serving on a 3 recipes for 2 people box (6 servings), ongoing weekly subscription. Only price break shown; larger boxes may work out cheaper	My Foodie Box Quoted per serve rate shown in the box builder for 2 servings across 3 recipes (6 serves per week), ongoing weekly subscription. Larger boxes are likely cheaper per serve but no rate was published for them.	Pepper Leaf Recipes are listed at "From $18.50" without stating whether that figure is per serve or per recipe, and no box price table or per-serve rate by box size was published, so no defensible standard per-meal price could be established.
First-order offerNot included in the ongoing price	Dinnerly	My Foodie Box Headline claim that meals start at $6.25 per serve	Pepper Leaf Free seasonal fruit added to your first two orders
Delivery fee	Dinnerly $11.99 shipping per box	My Foodie Box Flat $9.95 delivery fee on every box	Pepper Leaf
Order without a subscription	Dinnerly NoSubscription required	My Foodie Box NoSubscription required	Pepper Leaf NoSubscription required
Delivery	Dinnerly	My Foodie Box	Pepper Leaf
Delivers to	Dinnerly NSW, VIC, QLD, WA, SA, TAS, ACTMetro areas only	My Foodie Box NSW, VIC, WA, ACT	Pepper Leaf NSW, VIC, QLD, SA, ACT
Delivery days	Dinnerly	My Foodie Box	Pepper Leaf Monday, Saturday
Order cut-off	Dinnerly Recipe swaps, skips and cancellations must be made 7 days before your next delivery	My Foodie Box Monday 11:59PM AWST for the following week	Pepper Leaf
Food and nutrition	Dinnerly	My Foodie Box	Pepper Leaf
Meal type	Dinnerly Meal kitIngredients and recipes, you cook	My Foodie Box Meal kitIngredients and recipes, you cook	Pepper Leaf Meal kitIngredients and recipes, you cook
Fresh or frozen	Dinnerly Fresh	My Foodie Box Fresh	Pepper Leaf Fresh
DietsTinted where not every service compared offers it	Dinnerly Weight loss Low carb Vegetarian or vegan	My Foodie Box Weight loss High protein Low carb Vegan Vegetarian or vegan Gluten free Dairy free	Pepper Leaf
Calories published	Dinnerly No	My Foodie Box No	Pepper Leaf No
Full macros published	Dinnerly No	My Foodie Box No	Pepper Leaf No
Menu size	Dinnerly 300+ items	My Foodie Box 40+ items	Pepper Leaf
Ratings and checks	Dinnerly	My Foodie Box	Pepper Leaf
Customer rating	Dinnerly 3.7/5Highest1,346 reviews, Trustpilot	My Foodie Box 2.6/54 reviews, Trustpilot	Pepper Leaf 2.3/57 reviews, Trustpilot
Our score	Dinnerly 49/100Highest	My Foodie Box 27/100	Pepper Leaf 23/100Scored on 75% of our criteria
Prices checked	Dinnerly 24 August 2026	My Foodie Box 24 August 2026	Pepper Leaf 24 August 2026

Change the services compared

Service 1

Service 2

Add a third

Pick two or three services.

Strengths and trade-offs

Dinnerly

Budget-conscious families cooking quick weeknight dinners

One of the cheapest meal kits going, with servings from $8.99 and Saver recipes cutting $1 to $1.50 more per portion
Very large weekly choice, with 300+ recipes and filters for kid friendly, carb conscious, vegetarian and vegan
Five-ingredient recipes with most meals ready in 20 to 30 minutes
Shipping adds $11.99 per box, which lifts the real cost of small orders noticeably
Delivery limited to major cities and a few regional centres, with no Northern Territory coverage
Recurring subscription with automatic weekly billing unless you skip or cancel

Dinnerly review Visit site

My Foodie Box

Households wanting an Australian owned meal kit with dietary filters and eco packaging

Weekly menu of roughly 27 to 40 recipes with filters for low carb, low calorie, gluten free, dairy free, vegan and vegetarian
Choice of 2, 3 or 4 serve portions and 3 to 5 recipes a week, so it scales from couples to families
Recyclable and compostable packaging, plus the old box is collected when the new one is delivered
Flat $9.95 delivery fee on every box adds to the cost of smaller orders
Per serve price of $15.33 on a small 2 serve, 3 recipe box is steep next to the $6.25 headline rate
No kilojoule or macro figures published alongside the menu, only dietary tags

My Foodie Box review Visit site

Pepper Leaf

Home cooks wanting locally sourced meal kits, including single serve boxes

Box sizes for one, two, three, four or six people, so solo cooks are properly catered for
Choice of 2 to 5 nights of recipes per week, with pause or cancel at any time
Ingredients sourced from named local farms, delis and wholesalers, delivered within 72 hours of supply
No calorie or macro information published for recipes
Delivery restricted to selected cities and regions in five states, with no WA, TAS or NT coverage
Per serve pricing is not clearly set out, only a "from $18.50" recipe price

Pepper Leaf review Visit site

Compare other services

Two of these

Instead of Dinnerly

Instead of My Foodie Box

Instead of Pepper Leaf

How to read this comparison

Prices: The ongoing price at a typical order size: per meal for ready-made meals, per serving for meal kits. First-order offers and delivery fees are not included. Prices checked 24 August 2026. Confirm at checkout.
Highlights: Green cells mark the lowest published price, the highest customer rating, the largest menu, the highest minimum protein, our highest score, and a Yes where the services differ. A row is only highlighted when every service compared has a value for it. Prices in different units and ratings from different review platforms are not highlighted.
Customer rating: Out of 5, with the review count and the platform the rating is from. It is a customer rating, not our score.
Our score: Out of 100: customer rating (35 points, weighted by review volume), disclosure of macros, calories and a real price (20), price against services of the same type (15), menu size (10), ordering flexibility (10) and delivery reach (10). Where a provider publishes nothing for a criterion, it is dropped and the rest are rescaled.

Every service we list, with filters for diet, price and one-off ordersCompare All Meal Delivery in Australia